Replay won't overturn this terrible call, a breakdown

brought to you by SeatGeek. And then

we've got a little flare shot to left in

front of the fielder. He decides to run

on it. And out says the umpire. And

third base coach is like, "Are you

kidding me?" Boy, how could you say he

was out? It's Gage Tater Workman. It was

safe the entire time. He's looking

around like what? What'd he say? AJ

inch. He says, "Hold up. We're

deciding." Yes, we want to review it.

They go to replay. Here's one angle. The

helmet falls off in front of his face.

So, he's just a blinded man. And let's

watch and let's watch and let's watch.

And if his hand is touching there, you

would say, "I think he's safe." But is

that glove touching in the back? Was any

part of it touching? because we see it

touching the back right there. All

right, so they have a flip angle, too.

Let's check that out. Here we go. The

tag coming in and right. Okay, and now

let's really figure it out. Everybody's

favorite segment. Science by editing

backed by no one, trusted by few. Here's

how I'm doing this. Let's find the

moment we can guarantee we're like, I

know he's touching the bag. And pause it

right there. Okay. I don't think yet. I

don't think yet. Maybe he's touching.

Okay, right there. I think he's

touching. And but right, I guarantee

he's touching the bag right there. I am

for sure. So, let's look at the angle of

the helmet. Didn't think I was going to

do that, did you? Boom. All right. I

mean, it's it's tilted. Uh, it's not

parallel, but it's not the brim isn't

facing completely downwards. The butt of

the helmet isn't facing the sky. Now,

let's take the other angle. When can we

guarantee he is touching him? Right

there. I don't I can't guarantee you

that. But if you watch the jersey right

there, you see that jersey wrinkle

right? Watch the N on uh uh Gage Tater

Workman's jersey. Boom. It gets wrinkly.

See it right there. So, I'm positive

he's touching him there. Well, let's

let's take a look at that helmet. What?

Oh, it's way deeper into its rotation

when we guarantee he's touching him than

when we guarantee he's touching the bag.

Look at that. It's a whole couple more

rotations. The butt of that helmet when

the glove touches the shoulder is facing

the air. Not so much the other way. So,

science by editing says he's safe. Okay,

we're using a third party system. Let's

see what Jordan Baker, the tallest dump

in the history of MLB, has to say.

>> Detroit will lose the show.

>> The call on the field stands and the

runners out. Everyone is dismayed. What?

What are you talking about? Hinch says,

"Uh, it's right there.

They showed the play on the screen."

"It's not me. Don't get mad at me." He's

saying, "I didn't make the call. I'm not

the third base something, nor am I the

replay official in New York, so don't

yell at me." To which AJ Hinch responds,

"Fuck off. Come on." Oh, you're done.

Ejected. Not going to tell me to f off

now. AJ Hinch comes running out and he's

going to play innocent. George, what's

your problem?

Well, you can't tell me. Well, you can't

tell me. DON'T POINT OFF. DON'T

point at me. You You don't tell ME

I didn't say off. You didn't say

off.

>> I didn't say off. Yes, you did.

When they show the play on the

screen,

>> which is not your fault, it's his fault.

I understand. He up the play.

Gotcha. Okay. They show it on the board.

Correct.

>> We got to show you guys the play. Now we

have to fix it. I think he's

saying, "Show the umpires on the field

the play so they can do it. Why are we

sending it to New York?" I don't I'm not

positive what he's saying there, but I

think he's saying, you know, if you're

going to show it to everybody on the

screen, why don't we just make the call

here now? we have to fix it or face it.

I don't know. That's fair enough. And

then he walks away and he's on his way.

I agree with Hinch that they got the

call wrong. I disagree with him that he

didn't tell Jordan Baker to off

only because it looks like that right

here. He says, "OH, OFF." But maybe

that was just like to the whole world,

not to B. I wasn't talking to you,

Baker. Was talking to everyone, the

whole system, everything. So, it should

have been safe at third. Maybe a run

scores. Instead, it's an out. And then

the Mets turn an inning ending double

play. So, what could have been first and

third, no out becomes nada, nothing

nothing.

What do you guys think? Out or safe? And

do you think that Hinch told him to f

off? And be fair and be honest about it.

Thank you very much for tuning in. This

breakdown was brought to you by Segeek

and they're giving you 10% off any

ticket. You just got to use code

jambboy10

at seatgeeek. Go to the app, find a

seat, make sure it's good value. Get 10%

off with Johnboy 10. Thank you very much

for watching.