In recent seasons, the Oakland Athletics have found themselves navigating tumultuous waters, struggling to find consistency amidst a roster in transition. Fans have witnessed a whirlwind of emotions, from controversial umpire calls that have sparked heated debates to bizarre on-field mishaps that seemed to defy logic. This breakdown page will dive deep into those chaotic moments, featuring gripping highlights from games against the Yankees and Orioles where every call and play was magnified under the spotlight. Get ready to relive the tension as we explore pivotal plays that not only shaped the outcomes of games, but also added to the A’s unpredictable narrative in the ever-competitive landscape of Major League Baseball.
Most Popular Oakland Athletics Breakdowns of All Time
Third base umpire makes back to back wrong calls
Things got chaotic in Oakland as the Yankees faced the A’s in a game filled with questionable calls and heated reactions. One of the early turning points came in the third inning when an A’s runner stole third. The call on the field was safe, but replays showed the glove touched the jersey before the hand reached the bag.
View count: 1,601,522 (last updated at conclusion of 2025 season).
Centerfielder steals ball from left fielder
Kevin Kiermaier and Randy Arozarena had a weird moment in the outfield during a game tied 1-1 in the sixth. A routine sac fly to left should have been Arozarena’s play. He called for it, got behind it, and had momentum lined up to throw home.
View count: 1,447,481 (last updated at conclusion of 2025 season).
Ump says Mancini attempted to go to 2nd and calls him out
Things got heated during the Orioles-Athletics game in Oakland when Trey Mancini was called out on a controversial baserunning play. Mancini hit a comebacker that deflected off the pitcher and ended up with the second baseman. The throw to first was off, and as Mancini retreated to the bag, the catcher tagged him out.
View count: 1,240,209 (last updated at conclusion of 2025 season).
Ramón Laureano and the Oakland A’s get into a little dust up
Things got tense in Oakland with a brewing feud between the A’s and Rangers boiling over. The backstory started on June 8 when Mark Canha homered off Rangers pitcher Samson. As Canha rounded the bases, Samson told him to run, sparking a back-and-forth exchange.
View count: 1,017,511 (last updated at conclusion of 2025 season).
Umpire calls a Clear foul ball a home run
Clayton Kershaw faced Steven Piscotty and nearly gave up a home run on the first pitch. Piscotty smashed an inside fastball down the line, and everyone paused waiting for the call. The ump initially ruled home run, but Kershaw and catcher Austin Barnes were not buying it.
View count: 985,666 (last updated at conclusion of 2025 season).
The Latest Oakland Athletics Breakdown Videos
- A’s manager Mark Kotsay wants to review two plays at once, a breakdown
- Umpire upset both the Athletics and the Giants, a breakdown
- Umpires don’t call infield fly and A’s turn bizarre double play, a breakdown
- Batter ejected for drawing a line, a breakdown
- Domingo Germán throws a perfect game, a breakdown
- Ump says Mancini attempted to go to 2nd and calls him out, a breakdown
- Third base umpire makes back to back wrong calls, a breakdown
- Centerfielder steals ball from left fielder, a breakdown
- Umpires Get Replay Wrong in Oakland and Tampa Bay Game, a breakdown
- Umpire calls a Clear foul ball a home run, a breakdown
- A’s win the season opener with a walk off grand slam, a breakdown
- Yandy Diaz hits two home runs in the Wild Card Game, a breakdown
For the full list of Oakland Athletics breakdowns, visit the Oakland Athletics tag page.