Scary umpire ejects Ryan Howard after two check swing calls, a breakdown
What Happened
In the bottom of the 14th inning of a high-stakes August game, Philadelphia Phillies slugger Ryan Howard steps up to the plate looking to spark a late-inning rally. The Phillies have two runners on base, and Howard - just back from injury - is eager to be the hero. The first pitch from Houston Astros pitcher David Carpenter results in a swinging strike. On the next offering, home plate umpire Scott Barry rules that Howard went around on a check swing, drawing an angry reaction from the big first baseman. Howard puts his hands on his hips in frustration, leading to a sassy exchange with the umpire. "Oh, I can do that, too, dude. I can put my hands on my hips, too," Barry retorts. As the argument escalates, a fan in the stands yells, "You suck!" Barry turns and firmly tells the fan, "It's not between you and I. It's between me and him, man. It's not between us." The Phillies' dugout umpire tries to calm the situation, but Howard remains heated, telling the umpire, "It's not between you and I. It's between me and him." With tensions high, Howard steps back into the batter's box, still visibly upset. He hits a dribbler for the second out of the inning, bringing the go-ahead run to third base. Carpenter then fans Howard on a check swing, leading to Howard's ejection after he shouts, "Oh, f*** you, Scott!" The Phillies are forced to move left fielder Raul Ibañez to first base, while starting pitcher Roy Oswalt takes over in left field - a rare sight. Oswalt makes a smooth play on a fly ball, drawing a standing ovation from the dedicated Phillies fans who have endured this marathon 15-inning affair. Despite the lineup shuffle, the Phillies are unable to capitalize, eventually falling to the Astros in 16 innings. But the game will be remembered for the heated exchange between Howard and umpire Barry, as well as the unique defensive alignment that saw a starting pitcher patrolling left field in extra innings.
Full Transcript
Click timestamps to jump to that momentThe year is 2010 and the inning is the
bottom of the 14th. The Phillies have
two runners on. Ryan Howard is up at the
dish, grooving and feeling good.
Actually just came back from injury and
was still looking to get to a hot start.
Wasn't having a great night at the dish.
But it could all change if he's the hero
right now. First pitch swings through
it. Down 0 and one. Next pitch, did he
hold? Did he hold? puts his hands on his
hips because he's frustrated that he
swung or that the umpire said he swung.
Umpire Scott Barry said, "Oh, I can do
that, too, dude. I can put my hands on
my hips, too." Oh, what of it? Sassy.
THIS FAN SAID, "YOU SUCK."
OH,
PATHETIC.
Scott Barry's like, "Uh, oh my god, it's
not between you and I. It's between me
and him, man. It's not between us." So
the homeplayed umpire must have told him
like, "Hey, man. stop complaining, blah
blah blah blah. And Ryan Howard is
telling him, "It's not between you and
I. It's between me and him." And the
Home Plane umpire's like, "Uh, oh
okay." And then it looks like Ryan
Howard saying like, "I'm just mad at
myself. Can't be mad at myself, huh?
Fuck." Scott Barry still staring, still
engaged, still got a crazy look in his
eyes. Ryan Howard trying to step away
walk it off, spits in the batting
gloves, double grip, little trick. Steps
back in, hits a little dribbler. Now
there are two outs. The footage I got
didn't have a score bug. So right now
there's two strikes, there's two outs.
What do I do with this ball? Bam.
Wallace, tell me everything you know
about that guy. Then another ball in and
the runners advance. So now the go-ahead
run, the bubblegum run, the Gatorade run
is at third base. We got a high fast
ball. fouls that one back. Stays locked
in. Two strikes. Stay locked in. Stay
locked in. Milansen throws another
curve. Did he go this time? Yep. And
I'mma stare at you. And Ryan Howard
says, "Oh, [ __ ] you, Scott." Which you
gone. That gets him ejected. That gets
him ejected, right? I'll throw my
helmet, too. And then the homeplayed
umpire is trying to come out to him and
be like, "Hey, Ryan, Ryan, Ryan, calm
down. Calm down." And he says, "Don't
you [ __ ] talk to me. Don't you
[ __ ] talk to me. Don't [ __ ] talk
to me. NO. WATCH OUT. THAT'S [ __ ]
[ __ ] SCOTT. THAT'S [ __ ]
[ __ ]
[ __ ] twice, you [ __ ]
[ __ ] you.
[ __ ] you, Scott.
All you [ __ ]
[ __ ] Scott Barry just taking it in.
Still, he hasn't really changed at all.
That's just kind of what he does. He
stares. I think he was a minor league
replacement umpire at this point. The
next season he got called up, graduated.
Congrats. Good job. You know, [ __ ] you.
Howard didn't think so. [ __ ]
He's upset. It's the 14th inning. He
gets ejected. It's a big game. The crowd
is packed for a 14th inning game in
August. Throws the mouthguard. Scott
Barry still just looking the same.
Chomping the gum. Howard has to leave.
It's been a long game anyway. Oh my god
look at the intensity in those eyes. Oh
wow, that is scaring me. Is that scaring
you? Scaring me? Is it scaring you?
Because it's scaring me. Is this man
scaring you? Attention. Is this man
scaring you? Cuz he's scaring me. Yeah.
So, geez. Here's the here's the play.
Did he swing? I mean, today that gets
called. Every year umpires graduate
swings. Like in the 1960s, they wouldn't
even appeal this. 1970s they wouldn't
even appeal this. But I think my brain
what I've been watching recently, that's
a swing. [ __ ] you, Scott.
Oh. Anyway, so Raul Abanz had to go from
left field to first base. He hadn't
played first base in five years. These
are the only innings he played at first
base, but it's the 15th inning. They're
out of players. And who went to left
field? Starting pitcher Roy Oswalt.
Starting pitcher Royalt goes to left
field. So you got a pitcher in left
field. They shag balls before every
game. Easy peasy. It's the top of the
15th inning and the first pitch, of
course, it goes to left field. Oswalt
grabs it with ease. Throws it in. Didn't
look like a position player, but made
the play and standing ovation from the
full crowd who was still there in the
15th inning on a hot August night. I
don't know the temperature. And look at
look at look at Roy smiling, laughing.
Does he kind of look like Harvey Lee
Oswwell? Hey, here's the replay in
position. A little shuffle, gets under
it. Nothing to it. Two hands, gets it in
quick. The next batter grounds out back
to the pitcher. He feels it, grabs it
corrals it, throws it to our guy Raul at
first base, nothing to it. And then
Chase Utley is going to talk to Abanz
and he's going to say, "Hey, this next
guy probably going to bunt on you. Okay
so be ready for the bunt. You're going
to crash. I'll go cover." Or he's like
"All right, cool. I got you. I play
baseball. I know what's going on. Let's
do it. Used to be over here all the
time. And just like Chase said, we get a
bunt to the first baseman. Why not test
him? The inning opens with the left
fielder who's brand new making a play.
It ends with the first baseman who's
brand new at the position making a play.
Throws it into the crowd. I mean, the
momentum is as high as it's ever been.
Now, Phillies are going to win. The
crowd's on their feet. Everything has
happened. The ejection changed the
momentum. People playing out of
position. Uh, it didn't work out that
way. It's still a nice play. Gathers it
dives, takes it himself. Pitcher loves
it. Umpire loves it. Raul loves it. Bam.
But if we cut to later in the night
it's now 12:15, 12:16. We can read
clocks. We're getting tired. The
Phillies have lost the lead. It's the
bottom of the 16th inning. What was fun
is now seeming like we sat through all
of this for this, but they put together
a rally. We got a walk. Okay, we got a
base runner. There's two outs. And we
got Roy Oswald on deck. So Chase Utley
you're not going to see a pitch. They're
going to intentionally walk him to get
to the pitcher who's playing left field
and batting fourth.
Let's go Oswalt.
Let's go Oswalt.
Let's go Oswalt. The fan is ready.
Strike one. Oh, strike two. Okay. Oh
and hole. We got a Wum. Woo. Woo. Excuse
me, sir. Can't lean on the dugout like
that. You can't be woo. Dad, I thought
you said we could wooga, but it Did it
work? Ball. Ball. Oh, yeah. This is
[ __ ] hilarious.
Yes. And then ball in play to the third
baseman. He gobbles it up. He's going to
throw it to first. Phillies lose. Astros
win. Got to give credit to those
Phillies fans for staying strong and
being engaged the entire night. That is
awesome. Thank you guys for tuning in.
Appreciate you, Scott Barry. You scare
me. You're scaring us.