Fined for criticizing the call on this play, a breakdown
What Happened
In the bottom of the first inning of a close game between the Cleveland Guardians and the Detroit Tigers, the game takes an unexpected turn. With two outs and a runner on base, Guardians catcher Austin Hedges sets up behind home plate, ready to receive a pitch from the pitcher. The ball is delivered, and Hedges blocks it, keeping the runner from advancing. However, the umpire makes a controversial call, ruling that Hedges has violated the "blocking the plate" rule, which is designed to protect catchers from collisions at the plate. Hedges, clearly frustrated by the decision, expresses his displeasure, saying, "It's a disgrace. It's embarrassing." His criticism of the umpires' call results in a fine from the league. analyzes the play, noting that the "blocking the plate" rule has been in place for several years but has rarely been enforced in the way it was in this particular instance. , the host of , suggests that the rule is "tricky to define" and that the umpires have been "taking runs off the board more than they ever have" when it comes to these types of plays. provides further context, explaining that in a recent game between the New York Yankees and the New York Mets, there were similar plays at the plate that helped better understand the league's interpretation of the rule. He notes that the umpires want to see the catcher not cross the home plate or foul line until they have possession of the ball, which is not what happened in the Guardians-Tigers game. Ultimately, the umpires review the play and overturn the call, ruling the runner out. However, the damage has already been done, as the Guardians had to bring their pitcher, Trevor Pelaez, back into the game, and he subsequently gives up a three-run home run, a pivotal moment in the contest. emphasizes the significance of this play, stating that it "is why Hedges was so upset" and that the rule will likely come up again in the postseason, with potentially impactful consequences. He encourages viewers to check out the Rose Rotation podcast to hear Hedges' full thoughts on the situation, as the catcher had a strong reaction to the umpires' decision.
Full Transcript
Click timestamps to jump to that momentit's a plane that's been called a few
times now recently that really has never
been called before there's plays at home
that are beating the runners
and
for 150 years you're out and now we're
calling
some type of rule that
is really tricky to uh to define
uh honestly it's a disgrace it's
embarrassing austin hedges got fined for
that criticism of the umpires and the
umpires also released a response and
said get off her back this breakdown is
brought to you by draftkings let's take
a look because it is that rule that is
hard to define they are taking runs off
the board more than they ever have we're
in the first inning of a guardians
tigers game there's two outs a runner on
got fastball inside and then that's a
knight what is that a sinker splitter
it's a nice pitch o2 they go back to the
fastball up to set up the curveball down
hedges putting his glove down like get
it down he doesn't get it down but it's
fouled back and now hedges like come on
let's get it down let's get it down i'll
block it i'll block it blocks it keeps
it in front of them but the runner was
just
moving now he's in scoring position one
two count fastball uh
oh hits the base uh oh but they try
to go home easy out we got him out of
the inning we had a baseball
caused some chaos and biases out hedges
like
okay
okay we should have been a ground out
anyway but hinge says no let's review it
let's see if we can get him to overturn
it they've been doing this lately now i
did my best to figure it out and i think
i cracked the case cause
like hedges says
this has been standard forever
that's what catchers do they lay their
leg there they get the ball and they go
and tag
but
under the new rule which is supposed to
protect catchers
this is blocking the plate because he
did not give the runner a lane to get
his hand in
and i was thinking man that's so tough
like
he has the ball when he touches him
right he doesn't have the ball here but
there's no contact not blocking him
but there you go you can see the slide
bias has to do
he has to he can't just slide straight
because the plate's blocked yeah it
doesn't have a straight lane
so under the rule makes sense now i was
watching the yankees and the mats and
there was plays at the plates in that
game
that kind of gave me a better
understanding of what mlb
wants to see
they want to see
the catcher
not cross home plate or the foul line
until he has the ball so you see that in
this case higashioka he has the ball now
now he can do whatever he wants he can
fully lay his leg down and block the
path to the plate and it's out see he
can get in the way
but
this is the flip side and like austin
hedges says you're gonna have plays
where the ball beats the guy
but he's safe because mccann he's not
blocking the plate doesn't have the ball
yet has the ball so now he can try and
slide over and get in the way
but benny's in so if
bias could have done this slide
that ben and tendy does here would he
have been safe how fast that is that he
comes flying in and it's just direct and
there's no
spin movement at all that's what mob
wants to see so if baez was able to do
that would he have just went right past
him i still don't really think so but
i've there's no way to tell for sure
so they go to the booth and the umpire
comes back
[Applause]
he can't believe it and he's going to
look at me and says it's so bad
big time post malone vibes it's so bad
postman was a taller more athletic
no tattooed so bad it's kind of what
hedges looks like to me there so now
police act was in the dugout thinking
it's over he has to come back into the
game this guy hits a foul ball that guy
tries to bare hand he's like ah
ah
damn
ah
stinks
and they feel so bad for him she's like
here you want it it hurts you so bad
he's like yes thank you yes
got this thank you oh my goodness
wow
you see my hand stings fulton with the
hockey puck
and then the next pitch 2-2
high fastball home run
now that's a three-run
transition because the runner would have
been out that's one run police set goes
to the dugout he shuts his body down for
a little bit has to ramp it right back
up i wonder if he was allowed warm-up
pitches he had to be a lot of warrant
pitchers but still gives up the home run
what a game changer that's why hedges
was so upset
that's why he said what he said and the
umpires then find him and this that
guy's happy you can hear him talk about
this on the rose rotation and the look
on your face it was like they took your
puppy away have you seen your look that
you had
yeah
yeah i wouldn't have been going through
your mind i wasn't happy so go check out
the rose rotation to hear his full
thoughts on this i think get a cooler
head at the end but
it's a weird rule man because they're
calling it the rule has been there
for
10 years now or so maybe eight but it's
never been called like this because it
was to protect
catchers more so
than it was to
hinder their ability to make the play
and now the way the rule is being
implemented it's much more
hindering the catcher's ability to make
the play
the same way they've always made it than
it is to protect them hey this one was
brought to you by draftkings thank you
very much to draftkings for sponsoring
the video you know
this is going to come up in the
postseason it's going to happen a run's
going to come off the board and
everyone's going to be like
maybe we should have taken care of this
when we
had the chance